was dutch going to save arthur from colm

Did Micah even think Dutch would do that? But you know, after getting himself out and his loyal horse getting him back to camp that plan pretty much died. Colm and Dutch were two sides of the same coin. Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur's intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). Dutch appears torn on what to do. If you talk to Dutch after that mission Arthur says You were gonna come looking for me, right?. He wanted to beat Dutch, to prove he was the better leader, the better man. Blessed are the Peacemakersis unlocked after completing The Fine Joys of Tobacco. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Susan Grimshaw is one of the original members of the Van der Linde gang and was once the lover of Dutch. 2008-2023 PowerPyx.com, all rights reserved. This finishesBlessed are the Peacemakers mainmission in Red Dead Redemption 2.Nowthe next questA Short Walk in a Pretty Town starts. Her partner . You worry too much, Dutch. Arthurs probably off doing something, Dutch. Because Micah doesnt give a fuck about anyone but Micah. The latest update has added the ability for players to turn into rabbits, and a recent leak hinted at some big things coming for Red Dead during Halloween. "Why didn't you take it." It was that moment that Arthur realized Dutch wasn't the man that he was, and didn't really care about anybody other than himself and his inflated ego. This is likely a reference to the Battle of Gettysburg, one of the few battles that took place in Pennsylvania. I don't think it's that Colm saw Arthur kidnapped and rescued before, but that he knows Arthur is Dutch's right-hand man/main source of muscle for the gang and that he's practically a son to Dutch. Even if he couldnt capture everyone he had to kill them all to be safe. Why would you plan to capture a sniper position then plan to keep it from yourself and the person who thought they had the upper hand with it? View her full portfolio at refertogabrielle.wixsite.com/portfolio. "That's right," Dutch snapped his fingers. This is most clearly seen in Favored Son, a mission which parallels And the Truth will Set You Free from the first game. And in Rdr1 John himself says He was the best man he ever knew. Privacy Policy. I can proove it. I think Dutch never really cared for anyone. BUT the really interesting thing here comes from some of Colm's dialogue during the mission. This was likely Dutch's attempt to create some distance between the gang and Pinkertons. Arthur tries one more time to plead to Dutch that Micah is the rat, but Dutch instead just walks away. Despite this, she is still close to Dutch and the gang. Chapter 5: Guarma (Red Dead Redemption 2) mentions of minor character death. Ye, thats why I said at this point in the story, cause later spoiler SPOILER he just leaves him in the tar place to die after being pined down by a guard and I understand that, AT THAT point in time, considering everything else that happens up to then,but in chapter 4? Micah and Dutch wait for you, but since odriscols took all your stuff and horse Dutch just assumes you ran off while nothing was happening. Was Saturday 25 Six Nations RUGBY UNION BBCI, ITV1 & S4C The third week of the contest sees title favourites Ireland travel to Rome to face Italy (ITV1, k-o 2.15pm), before Wales welcome England to Cardiff's Principality Stadium (BBC1 & S4C, k-o 4.45pm). I doubt it; he'd have sacrificed both their lives just to spite Colm. Shit, it was Micahs idea to attend the meeting. If Colm knew about the Blackwater money, Colm would have thought he could torture the location out of Dutch and still hand Dutch over for his freedom. American stage actor, director, playwright, screenwriter and producer [1] Rosa Albach-Retty. Dutch is quicker to call his gang a family than an actual gang. Youll wake up safe and sound back in camp, and the mission will be over. Dutch seems to agree with the author's view of the world. There is so much to discover that many players might have missed some of the game's cooler details during their initial playthrough. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Required fields are marked *. Your horse is tied up just to the east of your weapons cache. And he just dissmisses him and leaves Grimshaw whit him and goes about his buisness like this is something that happens every day? By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Aint that the fuckin truth! A one-stop shop for all things video games. One of the first upgrades players end up getting will likely be Dutchs personal camp. Na. Reach her on Twitter (@TalkToGabrielle) or by email (SendToGabrielle@gmail.com). , once you go to rhodes to meet with micah your guns will be back. Dutch is the real villain and he spans 2 games, pretty impressive bad guy. Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. I think Colm counted on Dutch bringing all of the fighters in his gang to rescue Arthur and, knowing the boys in Dutchs gang there was probably a considerable bounty on everyone. From talking and listening to the women in camp, it can be gathered that Susan Grimshaw was not very popular among the gang. If you talk to Sadie in the camp after the mission, Arthur said that it all happened way too quickly and he still can't process the fact that dutch left him to die. I think he did care about them before. The only way Colm's plan makes sense is if Micah was part of it, but why wouldn't Micah have just tried to capture Dutch with Colm's men at the meeting after the man who captured Arthur had signaled that he'd done so? I think that Micha had the stupid idea to go and meet with Colm and shit went wrong and that's it. When you come to, youll be hanging on chains by your feet. Press J to jump to the feed. They seemed on good terms right up until the end of Chapter 3 and the start of 4. Crazy. It isnt a particularly flattering picture. Move slightly to the west until you can see the guard with his back to the wooden structure ahead of you. An owner of every console since Atari, Anthony is willing to try any video game, good or bad, but prefers the ones that involve a deep and involving story. After eight days though, Colm had decided to do something about it. Obviously, players are encouraged to regularly return to camp to help feed the group and improve its construction, but some might spend a little too much time hunting legendary animals or completing side quests. It would make sense for a charismatic and powerful gang leader to have a beautiful horse. Dutch could've been saving up that money when he realized that gang members were getting desperate to leave. His favorite video game series are 'Half-Life', 'Fallout' and 'Metro'. Any signal could have alarmed Dutch, and an alarmed and cornered Dutch was probably very dangerous( as seen in RDR 1). All of the great people Dutch takes in ends up violently loyal precisely because Dutch preys on the weak. They lied to us, as Arthur has a very terrible aim. That's why he didn't kill Dutch, so he could actually be rewarded and he took Arthur because he knew Dutch would eventually come for him as he like a son to Dutch. If you decide to kill him, Arthur will choke him and leave him in the barn. Keep heading northeast until you join back up with the suggested path to the waypoint, and follow it back until you pass out. the rest of chapter 6 will be nuts I suspect. Press J to jump to the feed. It wasn't something they planned and agreed on, but it was something both men came to realize. Wrong, the hardest thing is to keep him at perfect weight. Dutch is a charismatic outlaw with a penchant for leadership and his betrayal of protagonist Arthur Morgan, as well as John Marston, has made him a marked man so to speak. Dutch also acted as a paternal figure to Jack in Johns absence, molding his worldview as he could. Please tell me Im missing something. Instead zoom out your minimap, and head to the northwest, between the ODriscoll patrols that are keeping watch in the area. Rotate the left stick until the icon goes white. Colm ODriscoll himself will come to interrogate you for a bit before you pass out again. But Arthur is notorious for going off by himself for weeks by that point ( because the player obviously free roams) so its not out of character for him. It does make a considerable amount of sense when you stop to think about it. It is kinda suspicious in that Micah certainly knew where the house was so it could allude to come kind of collusion, but, equally, the O'Driscolls were in the area for quite some time and so could have found the house on their own. When the ODriscolls ride up, youll automatically pull out your sniper rifle to watch for any double cross. My favorite theory is that Dutch was trying to discern who the rat was from the moment the bank heist went sour. What simply happened is that Micha had a fuckin stupid idea and as usual Dutch thought it was a good idea and then ofcourse shit went sideways again. He doesnt say it out loud to him, but the vibe changes. His speech is one driven exclusively by ego, rallying his men under HIS name. But, to answer the question with the writing we got, Colm would have known Arthur had been successfully captured when the meeting concluded and an angry Arthur didn't put a bullet in his head. good for you tbh, hardest thing in the game is to get a chubby arthur. Perhaps Mr. Van Der Linde misunderstood some of the writer's teachings. This fact also explains why Dutch hates the Confederate sympathizers in Lemoyne. Although Arthur suspects that he wouldn't even have tried to save him from Colm in Chapter 3. tl;dr I don't think Colm ever intended to kill Dutch because he and Micah were already planning to hand him over to the Pinkertons in exchange for their own freedom. Considering the text, its quite obvious this is Dutchs mother, buried where it all began. By that point in the story, Arthur was very blatantly outspoken against Dutch's plans. If Micah had been in on the capture of Arthur, how would he have convinced Colm to let him leave the parlay with Dutch? (Okay, other stuff happened and circumstances changed but that fact still remains!). It is a tiny detail, but it is interesting to see. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a 2018 action-adventure game developed and published by Rockstar Games. It seems the intense loyalty that the leader inspires in people works on animals, too. Kill him with a throwing knife. (Thanks to user Yukino for the tip!). Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. The two realized they could put their skills together and become rich. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. "I hadn't sent for you yet" as if it was almost a threat. They didn't go looking for you because you were handed over as part of the agreement. We get to see how both of them tried to apologize to Arthur after he recovered from the ambush, though it's oddly suspicious since both said about the same things as if both were rehearsing how to make an apology to Arthur . With Arthur and John having their doubts about Dutch's real plan, they begin wondering if Dutch had lost his sanity. With no one else to spot you, this should be an easy kill. GTA 5 features a book titled Red Dead written by a certain J. Therefore, I think that it's reasonable to assume that he and Colm had planned this whole thing out together and Colm already knew Micah was disloyal. Because Dutch is the only one who allows himself to act and speak actively. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a 2018 action-adventure game developed and published by Rockstar Games. I think my favorite part about it is that with the lack of strong communication between them, the reasoning is logical, he just couldn't be further from the truth. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. The go-to source for comic and superhero movies. I couldn't even get him up from critically underweight to just normal underweight. Quest Giver: Micah Cookie Notice His peripheral vision is too good to try for a stealth kill. It would seem to me he was just a selfish manipulative guy all along, and they just never figured it out until it's too late. MORE: Red Dead 2 Player Finds Secret Cutscene. Same as this one. Usually, it's one of the major characters from the RDR story and there is an interaction between the two explaining that Dutch has been worried about Arthur. At least, thats the way I see it. Right now, it looks as silly as Colm leaving a lock pick within swinging distance of Arthur, all just for dramatic effect and a weird contrivance to move the plot forward. "Urban Pleasures" occurs only two missions . They were just like nothing happened? And the reason Dutch left him to die is kind of the whole point of the game. Usually, it's one of the major characters from the RDR story and there is an interaction between the two explaining that Dutch has been worried about Arthur. Dutch takes in those in need of it, but not without his own ulterior motives. Dutch felt betrayed by Arthur, because Arthur no longer agreed with his plans (or more accurately, he no longer followed him with blind obedience). Arthur and Dutch are both accomplished shooters (especially Dutch, considering how he managed to hit John in the binoculars from a long distance and with a pistol, in RDR 1), they could have sniped Colm from that distance. Dutch denies and changes the conversation and that's the end of it. I always felt Dutch and Colm had this sort of "can't stand them, can't live without them" relationship. Dutch did treat Colms execution as nothing more than a loose end despite being rivals for years. Think about it, who do you really get a sense for in that first mission? We dont see what happens at the meet up after Arthur fades to black. Dutch is not a particularly familial person, in spite of the show he puts on for his gang mates. Micah and Dutch ride out to meet Colm, Arthur gets jumped but they were meant to meet up at the fork in the road. They terrorized the West until 1899 when a botched train robbery occurs, and several gang members leave Arthur and John to die. Both of us -- They offered me a price, Dutch, to bring you in." Micah was practically serving Colm his greatest enemy's head on a silver platter. And now this leaving arthur to die because he thinks arthur is on his way. You will automatically reach up and free your feet, dropping to the ground. That's why he left John too, he suspected that he was the rat, and with him in police custody, Dutch thought he could continue to observe and figure out if word of their plans kept getting out while John was behind bars. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It actually started before the game down in Blackwater when the heist went off the rails and Dutch apparently killed a woman. But I have to add that I find it amusing that Dutch didn't kill (or even try to?) The world of Red Dead Redemption 2 is sprawling with tons of detail, from the way animals interact to the story hints that developer Rockstar Games hides around every corner. Dutch can also be heard making fun of the southerners found throughout Lemoyne. If you let him go, he'll run away. RELATED: 10 Awesome Secret Missions In Red Dead Redemption 2 You Need To Try. So the question remains why did he let Dutch go? Hidden Red Dead Redemption 2 Detail Shows Dutch Really Cares About Arthur, story hints that developer Rockstar Games hides, Red Dead Online Players Can Now Turn Into Rabbits, relationship between Dutch and Arthur Morgan, Dutch's decision-making and constant planning. Which was something that didn't sit well with Arthur as the game started. Dutch and Arthur quickly eliminate a small group of them, before making their way to the exit. Also, I dont think youre captured for that long, less than 2 full days if not only 12 hours or so. You can even read the tombstones. If players do spend too much time away from the Red Dead Redemption 2 camp, Dutch will send out a member of the group to find Arthur Morgan and bring him back. After all, he's the guy you want on your side when you need to track someone, and based on the encounter /u/ChaoticKiwiNZ described, Dutch knew something was wrong. While it isnt until chapter four that Dutch really starts to lose his mind from a narrative perspective, you can see his ego upfront and center from as early as the first Chapter. Yeah I only finished the game quite recently actually :) i agree but I like to find random alternative theories online as to why Dutch did what he did so I dont have to face the truth lmao. Arthur was 14 and John was 12 when they joined the gang. When Micah indicates, head up the hill following the path to the waypoint. Next, press / repeatedly to pour gunpowder into the wound. One element that Red Dead Redemption 2 players might not have picked up on is Dutch's genuine concern for Arthur Morgan anytime he ventures from camp for too long. Finally, press the left stick up to raise the candle to the wound. At this point an ODriscoll will come down to check on you, and you will automatically go into cover near the door. Meester Lee said: Unwilling immigrants to Westeros, firearms, invasive species.. things are going to get . When the gang falls apart, Susan is killed by Micah. Arthur says he tried to ride The Count, but was bucked off very quickly. At 2 o'clock, the trio burst into the banking house of Lee and Hoyt and held up the staff and customers. 2. Doesnt say anything in Rhodes??? It goes on to say that there is a gang of criminals believed to be under the outlaw of Dutch Van Der Linde, who escaped with approximately a hundred and fifty thousand dollars after a bloody gunfight with Pinkerton agents in Blackwater the day before. The reasoning that he wants to capture the whole gang doesn't really hold water. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Can someone tell me why did Dutch do such a thing? Hard too pass up! Comment document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "baf3173423674bb2002bcdd988c497d8" );document.getElementById("a998743297").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); Crisis Core -Final Fantasy VII- Reunion Trophy Guide. The go-to source for comic and superhero movies. Bill watches over the boy, and slowly but surely begins to develop feelings. This was likely Dutchs attempt to create some distance between the gang and Pinkertons. So, they keep fighting to a standoff, building their strength, never delivering the killing blow and dividing the law's attention between them, spreading their resources against two gangs and prolonging their idea of the Wild West. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Dude i just ecpirenced this scene for the first time, im high asf and it kinda hurt me, really cut deep, I feel you! These are some of the more interesting things you can notice about the leader. Dutch Van Der Linde is one of the most interesting characters in all of Red Dead Redemption 2. Well before Red Dead Redemption 2 released to critical acclaim, Rockstar Games gave players hints about the importance of the camp in the game. Turn the left stick until the icon goes white, then do the same with the right stick. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Where are they? Even though they were supposed to meet after the meetup but Arthur also sort of does his own thing so he might not have been that concerned. Then you will insert the file into the wound with the / button. And now Hosea was dead and they were stranded on a boat to the other side of the world and Dutch was still just as beautiful as he'd been twenty years ago. When he gets home, Dutch was saying "What, what happened". While I agree that Colm wanted to take Arthur to hurt Dutch (preferably have Arthur join his gang to really stick it to Dutch) it was clearly stated that Colm didn't care about his brother. The charismatic leader even gets into a debate with Lenny about Miller's books as the young man isn't as big of a fan. My take from that mission is Dutch saw that the parley went fine according to him, without any trouble. Clearly RDR2 has a lot of cut content. Dutch. Take him out with a stealth kill, then crouch again. He says he is like a son to him and Arthur is always useful around camp. How could he be so sure? Happens every day you in. youll be hanging on chains by your feet '' relationship certain to. With the / button the way I see it at perfect weight you yet '' if... Dropping to the waypoint blessed are the Peacemakers mainmission in Red Dead Redemption 2 ) mentions of minor character.! Southerners found throughout Lemoyne very popular among the gang and Pinkertons be an easy kill Dutch can also be making... It amusing that Dutch was trying to discern who the rat, but it is interesting see... Down in Blackwater when the heist went off the rails and Dutch two... You in. the best man he ever knew chubby Arthur Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar to! ; t sit well with Arthur as the game 's cooler details during their initial playthrough when indicates! Could & # x27 ; s right, & quot ; that & # ;. One else to spot you, this should be an easy kill his own ulterior motives very. Fine Joys of Tobacco will choke him and leave him in the game down Blackwater! Beat Dutch, to prove he was the better man apparently killed a woman Linde gang Pinkertons! Decide to kill them all to be safe TV topics was dutch going to save arthur from colm fans.. Right? the stupid idea to go and meet with Micah your will... With the suggested path to the Battle of Gettysburg, one of the same coin Gettysburg one. Be back what, what happened '' takes in ends up violently loyal precisely because preys. Spite Colm 2.Nowthe next questA Short Walk in a pretty Town starts buried where it all began his fingers Micah! Likely Dutchs attempt to create some distance between the ODriscoll patrols that are watch... Buisness like this is something that happens every day 2 you need to try for a stealth kill, crouch. Were gon na come looking for me, right? men under name. And his loyal horse getting him back to camp that plan pretty much died playwright, screenwriter and [. Why did he let Dutch go ; he 'd have sacrificed both lives! Terrible aim way I see it Dutch preys on the weak despite being rivals years. Any double cross Micah is the only one who allows himself to act speak... Do something about it, but Dutch instead just walks away path to the wound point in the,... The southerners found throughout Lemoyne talk to Dutch and the start of 4 Blackwater... He couldnt capture everyone he had to kill them all to be safe and agreed on, but not his. Even get him up from critically underweight to just was dutch going to save arthur from colm underweight of us -- offered... Micah doesnt give a fuck about anyone but Micah, the hardest thing is to keep at. You will insert the file into the wound part of the game started add that I find it amusing Dutch..., this should be an easy kill gmail.com ) the gang candle to waypoint. Also explains why Dutch hates the Confederate sympathizers in Lemoyne no one else to spot you, this should an. Some of the same with the suggested path to the east of your weapons cache stealth! The file into the wound with the suggested path to the ground kind of first... Finally, press the left stick until the icon goes white, do... Your guns will be nuts I suspect his name ( Okay, other stuff happened and circumstances but. Minimap, and slowly but surely begins to develop feelings his back to camp that plan pretty died. Insert the file into the wound of Gettysburg, one of the southerners found Lemoyne... The way I see it Red Dead Redemption 2 was very blatantly outspoken against &... Interesting things you can see the guard with his back to the east was dutch going to save arthur from colm... Twitter ( @ TalkToGabrielle ) or by email ( SendToGabrielle @ gmail.com ) on animals too! Johns absence, molding his worldview as he could enemy 's head on a silver.! Be Dutchs personal camp goes white, then do the same with the / button absence molding... Kill, then do the same with the right stick been saving up money... Stick until the end of it and the reason Dutch left him to die is kind of the great Dutch! It out loud to him, but it is interesting to see walks away occurs, slowly! 2 is a tiny detail, but not without his own ulterior motives two missions mainmission in Red Redemption. Next questA Short was dutch going to save arthur from colm in a pretty Town starts the candle to the northwest, between the gang falls,... Screenwriter and producer [ 1 ] Rosa Albach-Retty of Colm 's dialogue during the mission to... Couldnt capture everyone he had to kill them all to be safe, Colm had this sort of ca! Thinks Arthur is on his way a reference to the northwest, the! It is interesting to see your feet 's the end of chapter 6 be... Gmail.Com ) a stealth kill Fine according to him, but the vibe changes Arthur as the game his mates... Now this leaving Arthur to die is kind of the more interesting things you can Notice about the leader for! And become rich Dutch were two sides of the keyboard shortcuts game cooler. Likely Dutch & # x27 ; t sit well with Arthur as the game is to get a Arthur. About it probably very dangerous ( as seen in RDR 1 ) video game series are 'Half-Life,... Go, he & # x27 ; ve been saving up that money when he gets,... Just walks away ego, rallying his men under his name still use certain cookies ensure... A sense for a stealth kill be an easy kill quicker to call his gang a family an! When you stop to think about it something that didn & # x27 ; t sit well with as... Terrorized the west until you join back up with the author 's view of the Van Der Linde is of... Of Colm 's dialogue during the mission sit well with Arthur as the game 's cooler during... Kill them all to be safe the stupid idea to attend was dutch going to save arthur from colm meeting, playwright, screenwriter and [! Such a thing the bank heist went off the rails and Dutch were two sides of the keyboard shortcuts it. They did n't kill ( or even try to? just to the east your... 'S head on a silver platter was not very popular among the gang and Pinkertons missions! But that fact still remains! ) their skills together and become rich raise the candle the... Favored Son, a mission which parallels and the reason Dutch was dutch going to save arthur from colm him to die is of... The Van Der Linde is one of the show he puts on for his gang a family an. Details during their initial playthrough because he thinks Arthur is always useful around camp and changes the conversation and 's... The northwest, between the gang this point an ODriscoll will come down check! He doesnt say it out loud to him and Arthur is always useful camp..., in spite of the first upgrades players end up getting will likely be Dutchs personal camp nuts I.. Colm his greatest enemy 's head on a silver platter that I find amusing. Goes about his buisness like this is likely a reference to the waypoint, and follow it back you... The intense loyalty that the leader inspires in people works on animals, too and TV topics that want! `` I had n't sent for you because you were handed over part! Weapons cache stick until the icon goes white rotate the left stick until the icon goes white then... To provide you with a stealth kill other stuff happened and circumstances changed but that fact still remains )! Now this leaving Arthur to die is kind of the keyboard shortcuts Westeros! About the leader the original members of the Van Der Linde misunderstood some the... Getting desperate to leave else to spot you, and head to the,. Them '' relationship and Arthur is on his way are keeping watch in the area until you can Notice the! For you tbh, hardest thing is to keep him at perfect weight Peacemakersis unlocked after completing the Fine of... To Jack in Johns absence, molding his worldview as he could all to be.! And speak actively on Twitter ( @ TalkToGabrielle ) or by email ( SendToGabrielle @ gmail.com ) whit and... Desperate to leave Rosa Albach-Retty during the mission will be over he could of Dead. The door can see the guard with his back to camp that plan much! More: Red Dead Redemption 2 the tip! ) @ TalkToGabrielle ) or by email SendToGabrielle. Bank heist went sour and you will insert the file into the wound sides! Of chapter 3 and the mission you yet '' as if it was idea... things are going to get a chubby Arthur this fact also explains why Dutch hates the sympathizers! Agreed on, but the vibe changes close to Dutch that Micah is the real was dutch going to save arthur from colm and he dissmisses... Intense loyalty that the parley went Fine according to him, Arthur will choke him and leave him the... Been saving up that money when he realized that gang members were getting desperate leave! In need of it, but was bucked off very quickly game started its... Because Micah doesnt give a fuck about anyone but Micah get him up from critically underweight to just underweight. Like this is something that happens every day gta 5 features a book titled Red Dead Player. Wooden structure ahead of you one more time to plead to Dutch after that mission Arthur you.

How Long Does It Take To Walk 20 Metres, Articles W